Why is this the relationship?

My husband and I recently played the video game, Devil May Cry 5. If you aren’t familiar with the franchise, it is worth checking out. But this blog post isn’t about the game, it’s about something that stood out to both of us in the course of the game. Nero, one of the main characters, has a girlfriend that is never seen on screen but comes up in three different scenes. She is the person Nero calls for emotional support. She is shown to be kind, thoughtful, and a partner who is there for him.

We asked ourselves, why does this portrayal of a healthy relationship with communication, respect, and obvious love stand out to us so much? The answer was because it is so rare to see love interests or romantic relationships portrayed in media in this fashion. We talked it out further and we realized what we tend to see are three different portrayals of love interests over and over again that do not show healthy relationships.

  1. The Motivator
  2. The Obstacle
  3. The Goal

And when you look at these in detail, they aren’t portraying relationships that should be idolized or mimicked. Don’t believe me?  Let’s break it down.

The Motivator 

“I didn’t kill my wife!” That is the main motivator for the main character in The Fugitive, where not only is he motivated to find the real man who killed the wife he loved, but to also prove his innocents.  This is such a common trope. The dead spouse, the dead fiancee/fiance. It doesn’t matter if they were murdered or died from some other mechanism, all that matters to drive the story and the hero forward is that they are no longer living. Why were they so important and loved by the main character? Who cares. No one knows. They are dead and that is the only thing that matters to the story. We have both seen this played out in movies, tv shows, video games, and books and it takes away all identity for the love interest. Talk about lame. And this isn’t even limited to romantic love! It drags familial love into its murky waters all the time.

The Obstacle

The love interest is something to overcome in this case. They might be holding the main character back from reaching their full potential. They could be incompatible with the main characters’ ultimate goals. Maybe they constantly undermine the character or in some other way set them up for failure. The romantic interest becomes a foil and adds conflict and tension to the plot. While it can make an interesting read, it means that the relationship being portrayed isn’t really healthy. There are major incompatibilities. There is a lack of communication. There is a desperate need for a breakup, therapy, or questioning of why these people even were together?

Need an example? Go watch the relationships on Friends between Rachel and Ross. It is horrible, unhealthy, and there is no reason they should be shipped together. Ever.

The Goal

This is the Princess Peach role. They are the ultimate goal that needs to be achieved. They are what the main character wants to accomplish. You can switch the love interest out with a treasure chest or a mannequin and it probably wouldn’t change the story much. Half the time this role is portrayed, I am never even sure if the main character actually knows the love interest. Are they in love with the person or the idea of the person they have built-in their head?

In conclusion?
Now we admit there are plenty of stories, movies, tv shows, and books that don’t fall into any of these three tropes. However, look over your favorite media. Like right now, I can wait, go look it over. Do any of these three roles for the love interest arise? (I hope the answer is no, but let’s be honest, you are probably saying yes)

What we want to see are relationships that show the couple as a team. We want effective communication, support, respect, honesty. We want to see the tension in the story come from outside the relationship or even if it’s internal, the couple to come together to deal with the issue. We want more of these relationships so the relationship in Devil May Cry 5 doesn’t stand out. Let’s flood the market with healthy relationships!

 

 

One thought on “Why is this the relationship?

  1. Excellent post. You are right that so many portrayals of couples are like this in movies and shows. The Punisher is a good example of this. He is motivated by the pain he feels from the murder of his wife and children. So yeah, I def see the motivator portrayal there. As for the show Daredevil, I def see Elektra portrayed as an obstacle in Season 2. You’re absolutely right that the Ross/Rachel relationship is unhealthy and awful.

    Those three portrayals you mentioned are definitely quite descriptive of so many relationships shown in film and TV.

    We absolutely don’t see healthy portrayals of relationships often enough. My goal for my SFF rewrite is to ensure that relationships are healthy ones. My MCs are best friends who do become a couple (Matt and Steph). They are honest and open with one another and support one another. Steph inspires Matt and he looks up to her. But they both will always be there for each other. I’m excited to write them and your post helps me remember important things to keep in mind as I write their bond (“effective communication, support, respect, honesty. We want to see the tension in the story come from outside the relationship or even if it’s internal, the couple to come together to deal with the issue.”) I can definitely see tension b/w them especially because Steph is calm whereas Matt is impulsive and again, I’m excited to write them.

    Excellent post, my friend! :). Your blog is great! :).

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s